Berlin’s big AI win
The EU's AI regulation, already a triumph of ambition over execution, has now been comprehensively hollowed out. EU ambassadors have agreed to Germany's demand to exempt machinery from the AI Act entirely, as part of a 'broad review' that also pushes back restrictions on high-risk AI and introduces a grace period for watermarking requirements. This is the same watering-down we flagged last week, now with added carve-outs for the industrial lobby. Because nothing says 'world-leading regulation' like letting the biggest economy opt out of the rules before they've even started.
The machinery exemption is a particularly exquisite piece of regulatory theatre. Germany's industrial sector, which includes everything from factory robots to automated tractors, can now merrily continue deploying AI without Brussels looking over its shoulder. The 'high-risk' category, which was supposed to be the teeth of the legislation, gets pushed back further into the future. And the watermarking grace period? That's just a polite way of saying 'we'll think about labelling AI-generated content next year, maybe.' One wonders what's left of the original proposal — perhaps a strongly worded letter and a shared sense of disappointment.
Meanwhile, the rest of the world watches and draws its own conclusions. The US is not going to be slowed down by such niceties, and China certainly isn't. The EU's approach, once hailed as a model, is now a cautionary tale of how to get caught between competing national interests and a tech sector that moves faster than any parliamentary process. The AI Act is still technically law, but it's starting to look less like a landmark and more like a gentle suggestion politely typed in Comic Sans.